10 min read

“The potential of carbon farming - a reality check"

Aug 26, 2021 9:23:09 AM

Carbon farming is an agricultural method which aims to sequester atmospheric carbon into the soil as well as into roots, leaves and wood.  It is also known under the term “regenerative agriculture” and includes numerous agricultural methods. 

The development of agriculture has become one of the central issues in society. This is because food production is responsible for one third of annual greenhouse gas emissions and is therefore a key contributor to climate change. Conversely, agriculture suffers from extreme weather conditions and farmers' harvest and livelihoods become increasingly uncertain. 

carbon farming blog 2

Source: IPCC, 2018

It becomes clear that a sustainable system is needed. One, that can feed the growing population and at the same time protect the planet. Carbon farming is one of several approaches pursuing this goal. It goes beyond sustainability. The aim of this principle is not just to keep land standing but to improve it. 

How it all started

This agricultural approach is not new. It has been around in the US for 50 years and is slowly but surely spilling over to Europe. According to current estimates, about 50,000 hectares in Germany are farmed according to the principles of carbon farming – on both organic and conventional farms. Carbon farming describes a system of farming principles that increases biodiversity, enriches soils, improves water systems and enhances ecosystem services. And it does so by restoring organic matter to the soil and promoting soil biodiversity. 

The focus is clearly on the soil. It has an enormous potential to store carbon and counteract climate change. Soil that is rich in carbon is also fertile, and fertile soil in turn is the basis for high yield and profitable agriculture. Thus, it is crucial for people’s food security. Scientists assume that if the global content of organic carbon in the soil increases by 0.4% annually, all climate-relevant carbon emission can be fully compensated. 

Principles of carbon farming

As already mentioned, it all started in the US and shortly after in Australia. Names like Joel Salatin, Gabe Brown, Dr. Ellaine Ingham and David Marsh are widely known in the circles. Gabe Brown's principles manifested in his book Dirt to Soil have been spread worldwide. In his book he explains how he converted an intensively cultivated area of 2,000 hectares into a regenerative one. The result speaks for itself: the humus content increased from 1.4% to 6-10% within 25 years. The humus build-up in turn ensured higher yields on his farm and sequestered CO2. Gabe Brown's five basic principles serve many farmers worldwide as a basis for conversion: 

  • Maximize biodiversity.
    • This means biodiversity in the soil as well as on the soil surface: earthworms, bees, etc.
  • Permanent ground cover.
    • The fields are cultivated with crops all year round through under sowing and catch crops. This supports humus build-up and prevents soil erosion.
  • Minimizing soil disturbance and synthetics.
    • This refers to the use of, for example, a plough as well as fertilizer and crop protection.
  • Integrating animals.
    • Animals move nutrients, feed the soil with manure and microbes or pollinate crops. Animals can therefore partially replace the work of machines. 
  • Keeping living roots in the soil.
    • Is the key to humus build-up, because the converted solar energy enters the soil through the root excretions. 

carbon farming blog 1

Source: L.E.K. analysis; modified by Michal Slota

Methods of carbon farming

So far, there is no uniform approach to what carbon farming should look like. There are a variety of methods, all of which pursue the same goal: Not to harm the land and soil, but to improve it. Versatile concepts are also being successfully implemented in small areas all over Europe. The most widespread approaches include:

  • Permaculture
    • A holistic approach to agriculture that promotes rather than exploits ecosystems and communities. The basic principles are: care for the soil, people and equitable sharing of the surplus.
  • Agroforestry
    • Perennial woody plants are used in the same area as crops and/or animals.
  • Holistic grazing
    • Animals are kept outdoors and moved regularly to allow plants sufficient time to recover from grazing and thus better store CO2.
  • Keyline design
    • This concept promotes soil fertility through water retention and redistribution. The result is the development of better soil structure and increased soil fertility for both cropland and pasture.
  • Crop Grazing
    • Using crops for grazing can help close the forage gap between autumn and winter and reduce the cost of supplementary feeding. Careful grazing management is needed to limit the impact on grain yield.

Building up humus to permanently store carbon in the soil takes time. However, it is worth the wait, because regenerative methods have two key advantages: they can counteract climate change and make agricultural systems more resistant to diseases, weather extremes and pests. Our food system would be protected in the long term. Additionally, farmers can reduce their expenses, mostly to a more efficient use of fertilizer, fuel and labor costs. 

Challenges of Carbon Farming

So, why isn’t every farmer doing this? There are several concerns. Farmers fear the conversion period of at least four years, during which expenses are usually higher than income and yields are lower. Moreover, there is a general lack of education about implementing carbon farming methods and a lack of needed machinery. So far, there hasn't been a scalable tool available which is measuring the success of carbon farming and the amount of humus that was built. This is one central challenge which has to be overcome, in order to make carbon farming more attractive, feasible and worth insuring. Anyhow, there are some promising attempts by startups. Though carbon farming has a romantic image, technology and carbon farming are not mutually exclusive. On the contrary, technology and digitalization can be helpful additions to the system. 

Solution approaches 

Where there is a problem there is or will be a solution. Young companies such as SmartCloudFarming and dagan are working on measuring the development of soil through satellite data collection. 

SmartCloudFarming, as a global acting company, is collecting satellite, soil and weather data, in order to feed the information into a developed Soil AI. The given information results in a so-called Soil Carbon Map. Through this map the potential of soil carbon sinks will be measurable and potential areas for carbon sinks can be located. SmartCloudFarming was part of RootCamp’s first batch. You can read more about them here.

Biochar on the other side is a key technology for decreasing emissions through enhancing soil buildup. It has been intensively researched in recent years. A number of experiences with its applications and innumerable scientific publications prove today that in addition to its direct climate benefit as a carbon sink, biochar can be used in agriculture in many profitable and beneficial ways. Biochar can help to increase yields, promote humus formation, increase the water storage capacity of soils and thus raise their resistance to drought, and reduce greenhouse gas emissions such as methane and nitrous oxide as well as nitrate leaching. 

Several startups have picked up this promising technology. Carbonauten, founded in south Germany, is successfully producing biochar from waste, like saw residues, wood chips and green cutting. The raw material can be used for agriculture in order to build humus and promote the ability of soil to capture carbon. 

In order to make carbon farming methods more attractive to farmers, companies have emerged, promising to support people and organizations to sequester carbon. CarbonFuture and Nori are examples for global acting players within this field. Whereas Klim or CarboCert mainly act in Germany and connect farmers with companies in this matter. Their aim is to make the market more attractive for farmers through giving them financial rewards for their effort. 

The EU approach

Carbon farming has also found its meaning in EU politics. The commission plans to launch the carbon farming initiative by the end of 2021, based on the positive results of a former study which showed that carbon farming can contribute significantly in tackling climate change. Therefore, the commission will promote carbon farming as a new green business model that creates a new source of income for actors in the bioeconomy. Besides, the commission will develop a regulatory framework for certifying carbon removals to monitor and verify the authenticity of carbon removal. 

Reality Check

What started on isolated small farms around the world and was often seen as a romanticized idea is now receiving serious attention from major players. Barilla developed a sustainable agriculture code in 2018. Other companies such as Danone, Mars and Nestle created a coalition to protect biodiversity in their agricultural activities. One of the coalition's three pillars is scaling up carbon practices. Outdoor brand Patagonia and Soap producer Dr. Bronner’s are also advocates of carbon farming methods.

With the segment gaining traction established players within the agricultural and fertilizer sector K+S, as well as Arkop work on supporting carbon farming methods on a large scale. Also new players are on the rise: e.g. Pivot bio is one of a bunch of companies trying to change the status quo through developing an alternative to synthetic nitrogen fertilizer in order to decrease negative effects they have on the environment.

Still there is a debate about what exactly accounts as carbon farming and what it can and cannot accomplish. Farmers are regenerative if they say they are. There are no labels, no certifications that claim carbon farming practices for themselves. Besides, each farm needs its own way of carbon farming adapted to the regional circumstances like climate and soil quality. There is not the one and only solution. To figure this out time and patience is needed.

RootCamp’s webinar “CARBON FARMING: challenge mapping and solution showcase”

RootCamp joined forces with DLG and hosted a webinar discussing innovation and feasibility of carbon farming. Major international players from established corporations as well as Startup founders were taking part on the 22nd of July in order to share their ideas and exchange thoughts. There were Rolf Härdter, Head of Agronomy and Advisory at K+S Group, Michał Słota, Sales & Business Development Specialist at ARKOP, Suvrajit S., CTO at SmartCloudFarming and Michael Sernatinger, International Sales Representative at carbonauten GmbH. 

➡️ Watch the recording here

Conclusions

Anyhow, with carbon farming we are at the beginning, which offers room for further development. It has the potential of forming the next agricultural revolution, but this requires courage, creativity, technology and strong partnerships. For carbon sinks to be created on the scale that is necessary, a carbon sink economy with appropriate financial incentives is needed. It is crucial that robust systems are developed that are auditable and that map the durability of carbon sinks and thus the actual climate impact with scientifically sound calculation methods.

Laura von Ketteler

Written by Laura von Ketteler

Laura is passioned about writing and innovation. After finishing her Master’s degree in Sustainable development at Uppsala University she has been working for renowned initiatives within the field of food production. She supports RootCamp as a freelancer in communications and is writing blog articles on current topics.

Drop in a comment

Our Ecosystem

SPINLAB_Logo

smart_infrastructure_hub_logo

SIV_Logo

 

Featured